Book review and synopsis for The Woman in the Window by A.J. Finn, a serviceable thriller and homage to Hitchcock's Rear Window.
The Woman in the Window is about Anna Fox, a former child psychologist, who is agoraphobic as result of post-traumatic stress disorder. When the novel opens, it's been around a year since she's left her house, though her husband and daughter are no longer living there.
She's depressed and drinks heavily and is on a medley of prescription drugs. Like The Girl on the Train and Hitchcock's Rear Window, she believes she witnesses a crime, which serves as the central mystery of the novel. Anna is a lover of old movies -- the classic black and white ones are the best, she tells us -- and the many references to Rear Window indicate the homage is clearly intentional.
Anna Fox is agoraphobic, meaning she gets severe anxiety if she leaves the house. She is also depressed, has a drinking problem and stopped working ten months ago. Her daughter, Olivia, lives with her husband, Ed (they're separated). A new set of neighbors, Alistair and Jane Russell, have moved in with their son, Ethan. Ethan is a troubled teenager, but he's nice and Anna gets to know Ethan and Jane. However, Alistair seems controlling and suspicious of Anna spending time with his family.
Anna hears screams from the Russells house. She calls, but Ethan says it's okay and his dad just lost his temper. However, later, Anna sees that Jane has been stabbed, and Anna calls the police. Anna tries to leave the house to help, but faints. When she awakes, Anna explains to the police what happened and that it was Alistair, but they say that Jane is fine and bring Jane over. But this Jane is a woman Anna has never seen before.
Anna starts making more efforts to leave the house in order to investigate impostor Jane. (Anna's agoraphobia arose from a car accident that left their whole family stranded and injured during a snowstorm. Anna feels guilty because they had been on vacation when Ed found out Anna had had an affair. They left early because of the discovery, which resulted in them getting caught in the storm.)
Anna knows she saw Jane get killed, but the police think she imagined it due to some combination of drinking and pills. The police say that they've talked to Anna's doctor. They know that Anna is delusional because Ed and Olivia are both dead (they died in that accident). Anna knows it on some level, but is in denial.
Anna shows Ethan a photograph, proof that Jane #1 existed. Ethan finally admits that it's his biological mother, Katie. That night, Ethan shows up to try to kill Anna (to keep her quiet). It's revealed that Katie is a former drug addict who came back to reconnect with Ethan, but he stabbed her. Ethan has always been a problem child with personality disorders due to his upbringing. Alistair had been trying control him, and lied to cover for him. In the end, Ethan dies in the scuffle. Alistair is arrested for the coverup. And a friend helps Anna take a few steps into the light.
This book has been popping up everywhere, like everywhere, and I love a good mystery. The Woman in the Window by A.J. Finn is a psychological thriller that has been compared to books such as The Girl on the Train and Gone Girl. It jumped to #1 on the bestseller lists upon release, fueled by a bidding war for the book (and accompanying film rights). Sounds promising, no?
Still From Hitchcock’s 1954 Film Rear Window
This book came out on the heels of another popular thriller, the Girl on the Train. Within the first few pages, it’s abundantly clear why there were so many The Girl on the Train comparisons. The set up seems oddly familiar. It opens with a woman who is voyeuristically looking through a window at other couples and people that she seems to have taken a deep interest in. Meanwhile, the woman herself is an isolated and depressed. She misses her estranged husband and is still in contact with him. Didn’t I just read this book? you can’t help but think.
I read Girl on the Train not too long ago, and the similarities between the two books were distracting for me in the beginning. Being led around by a narrator who was drunk and incapacitated all the time, unable to process what she remembered or thought she saw, was frustrating the first time around; I don’t know that it’s an experience I’d necessarily recommend twice in a row.
Despite my initial misgivings, when the mystery really gets underway, I found myself being drawn in. When the novel’s first real twist happens, I was surprised and pleased. The second half of the book sped by. The Woman in the Window twists and turns throughout the second half; some parts of it are more predictable than others, but even if you aren’t shocked at each turn, it’s a fun ride if you’re someone who enjoys trying to piece together or guess at what’s going to happen next. I figured out a pretty major plot twist fairly early on, but I still enjoyed the ride.
A.J. Finn is a pseudonym for Daniel Mallory, a former book editor for William Morrow, so the writing is predictably solid. In terms of the technical stuff, like pacing, etc. I have no qualms.
Like many thrillers, there’s a contrived quality to the story — plot elements shaped a little unnaturally for the purpose for having the mystery play out in a specific way, as opposed to for believe-ability or whatnot — and there’s still a few things that didn’t entirely make sense to me in the novel. For example, when Anna Fox reports what she saw to the police, for some bizarre reason, before they’ve even asked her about it, they bring in the person she is accusing and then ask her about it with them present? What type of detective operates like that? But I think these complaints are somewhat standard for most thrillers, and I don’t think they detracted from the story.
Read it or Skip it?
All in all, I thought The Woman in the Window was a perfectly serviceable mystery/thriller. I liked it slightly more than the Girl on the Train, but not by a lot. I’d recommend it if you are a fan of the genre (it helps if you have not read the Girl on the Train). Probably won’t end up being your favorite book or anything, but a good pick to scratch that mystery/thriller itch. For everyone else, you might like it, but will probably end up thinking it is a little over-hyped (which it is).
Author Daniel Mallory, pseudonym A.J. Finn
The Woman in the Window Movie Adaptation
The book is getting a movie adaptation starring Amy Adams and Julianne Moore. It was originally slated for a October 4, 2019 release, but test audiences found it confusing, so it has been pushed to 2020, pending reshoots and edits. It has since been acquired by Netflix, so it’s unclear when it’ll be released.
Controversy over A.J. Finn / Dan Mallory and Plagiarism
There’s also been a fair amount of controversy regarding A.J. Finn. See the New Yorker article here for all the gory details. Some of the stuff seems fairly benign, but weird like him faking some strange affectation when he talks. Other stuff is significantly worse like lying about having cancer and about his background. Also, Sophie Hannah makes an entertaining appearance in this, if you’re a fan of hers I’d highly recommend checking it out.
Furthermore, there’s been some discussion (in this New York Times article or read this if you don’t have a NYT subscription) about plagiarism. I haven’t read the other book in question so I don’t feel well-equipped to provide an opinion on that issue, but basically the book Saving April by Sarah A. Denzil seems to have a suspiciously similar plot (including the ending apparently).
Did you read it or are you planning on reading it? What did you think and would you read another book by this author? See The Woman in the Window on Amazon.
What similarities did you see in this book with the movie Rear Window that it pays homage to?
Where you surprised by the ending or did you see it coming? Did you think it was a good twist? How did it impact the way you saw the rest of the story?
How plausible did you think the book was? Did that have an impact on your enjoyment of the novel?
What do you think about the use of protagonists who are substance abusers? It seems to be fairly common right to in mystery novels — why do you think that is? Do you like it as a narrative device or no?
How did your impression of the characters change as the book went on?
What did you think the resolution of the book was going to be?
Did you find Anna to be a sympathetic character, why or why not?
Recommended Published January 2, 2018
Page Count 448 pages
Goodreads3.96 (out of 5)
From the Publisher
Anna Fox lives alone—a recluse in her New York City home, unable to venture outside. She spends her day drinking wine (maybe too much), watching old movies, recalling happier times . . . and spying on her neighbors.
Then the Russells move into the house across the way: a father, a mother, their teenage son. The perfect family. But when Anna, gazing out her window one night, sees something she shouldn’t, her world begins to crumble—and its shocking secrets are laid bare.
What is real? What is imagined? Who is in danger? Who is in control? In this diabolically gripping thriller, no one—and nothing—is what it seems.
I agree, the book was a fun mystery but the hype is overblown. I still had fun reading it though!
yup not amazing but I still enjoyed it too :)
Great review! I enjoyed this book, but it was a bit slow at times. That being said, I agree, I liked it better than Girl on the Train.
Thanks Malia! Yeah I definitely thought the beginning was slow, especially for a thriller, but still glad I finished it :)
What a great review! I liked the contrasts you made to Rear Window and Woman on the Train. Very thought provoking. Thanks for the review!
thanks for dropping by! :)
I wish PR would stop calling new books “the next gone girl” or saying “fans of gone girl will blah blah.” Just a thought!
haha fair enough, it is pretty overused :)
Sounds like an interesting read :)
Great review! I haven’t read The Girl on the Train yet, but I’m drawn to this book because it indeed reminds me of Rear Window! I really liked your comparisons to both!
thank you! yeah, if you’re into thrillers, I think this is a fairly solid one — hope you like it!
Very good review, thanks a lot!
Agree! Enjoyable but probably not anyone’s new favorite. Impressed you figured out that big plot twist! It hit me hard!
haha thank you! yeah, when I guessed what it was I kept hoping I was wrong but alas!
Very honest review..😃
Great review. I have it there to read, but there are a few on top of it as yet. Will be interesting.
Thank you! Hope you like it!
I’m currently reading The Girl on the Train..
Hope you like it! :)
This definitely sounds entertaining, even if it is a tad overhyped. Great review!
Thanks for your review! I’m still recovering from Girl on the Train…
Haha, totally understandable, thanks for dropping by!
It was because of the hype I picked this book up as well!!
Nothing wrong with that — I think plenty of people will genuinely enjoy it, so I don’t necessarily think it’s a bad thing. I just wanted to make the point that if you’re expecting something mind-blowing because of the hype, then you might be a tad let down. Thanks for dropping by!
Interesting review. I’m probably alone in having gotten bored with Girl on a Train, though I did kinda like Gone Girl. Maybe I should give this a whirl. I’m a great fan of crime fiction but my favourites are Ian Rankin and Nicci French
Honestly…if you thought Girl on a Train was boring, I think you might find this book boring as well, since the beginning is pretty similar tone-wise to Girl on a Train, but it actually moves somewhat slower. Have you read anything by Tana French? I like her books quite a bit.
I thought the book was pretty detailed oriented, with regards to making me feel like I was at the scene. Towards the end it got pretty interesting..a good read..
Haha, yes, the end ramps up quick, doesn’t it? Thanks for dropping by!
Thank you very much!
You’re welcome. 😊
I was wondering if I should read this book, now I think I will give it a shot :-)
Hey thanks for letting me know — I really hope you like it! Happy reading!
I love Rear Window! And since I’m such a sucker for all the marketing hype, this will be going on my to-read list. If I don’t read it, I’ll wonder each time I see a reference to it.
Haha, I hope you like it! It’s a fun book, overhyped or not, I certainly enjoyed it! Thanks for dropping by! :)
Terrific review Jennifer. I’ve gone back and forth over this but I have added it to my “to read” list for the future…
Thank you! Really hope you enjoy it! Happy reading! :)
I am putting this in my TBR pile for sure. Thanks for such a great review.
Hi Jackie, that’s great to hear! Thank you and thank you for your comments!
I’m planning to read The Woman in the Window. Your review is well done in giving your thoughts without spoiling the story!
Thanks. I think I’ll read this soon.
Thanks for the review. I liked Girl on the Train, but I probably am not ready for another book that is really similar. It’s good to know about though.
Nice review. I may get a sample – I like mysteries. Thamnks for reading my post.
The beginning is slow- fair warning! It gets better towards the middle
Hi: I wasn’t a fan of The Girl on the Train. However, this is still on my reading list: Cornell Woolrich’s 1942 short story “It Had to Be Murder”–they based the screen play of the Jimmy Stewart movie on the short story.
Oh interesting, I love short stories and will definitely check that out. Really appreciate the recommendation!
This one is on my list. I liked The Girl On The Train.
I bet you’ll feel similarly about this one, too! I wouldn’t recommend reading one directly after the other (break it up with some other stuff in between) but it’s definitely a good pick if you like mysteries! :)
I haven’t read it yet, but I do plan to.
I don’t think I’ll bother with it, but appreciate the good review.
Thanks for reading, Kate! Glad to be of service :)
I would have to agree. I liked it more than the girl on the train, but I was distracted because of the obvious similarities in the characters. Very different plot lines but the main characters unreliable narration were a little too close to not be distracting.
Yeah, it was hard to keep from continuously comparing the two which made it harder to get into the story in the beginning. Glad I read them though!
Thank you for a wonderful review. Another book I must add to that ever growing TBR list/pile *smile*
I thought the film and the book were Hitchcock inspired and enjoyed both, although I couldn’t remember the ending of the book. I think it was more detailed as these things tend to be as you inevitably have to reduce the number of characters in a film. Great cast, although Gary Oldman didn’t have much to do.
I was disappointed to learn about the author and his alleged behaviour, which spoiled the book for me.