Early on in the The Dreamers by Karen Thompson Walker, two college students discuss the Trolley Problem, a very popular thought experiment in ethical decision-making. It’s a scenario (would you kill one person to save five?) that has made its rounds again and again in academics, pop culture and in meme form, sometimes referred to jokingly as “trolleyology” due to how overplayed the topic has gotten.
When The Dreamers presents the topic sincerely without any wink at its triteness, it feels like the book is starting off on shaky, cliched grounds.
It’s a reminder that it’s an entry in the increasingly crowded genre of dystopian epidemics, this time about a sleeping disease that has hit California. And while there’s nothing inherently wrong with writing in a popular genre, it made me wonder if the book would have anything new to say.
In the Dreamers (to be released January 15, 2019), a disease has beset a college in California where people go to sleep but never wake.
As the highly-contagious sleeping disease slips into the general populace, the book follows a number of narrative threads to track the disease’s effects — a young couple with a newborn, two girls and their overprotective father, the college students who are quarantined in their dormitory, and so on.
Notably, people with the sleeping disease seem to dream exceptionally vivid dreams.
The premise of the book is reminiscent of her previous novel, The Age of Miracles. They’re both centered around a slowly progressing apocalyptic scenario and seek to explore people’s response to it. Whereas The Age of Miracles focused on one character and told the story from her perspective, The Dreamers has a broader scope.
But, while the wider sweep of The Dreamers could have made it a stronger book, it instead presents the issue of having a book full of partially-formed characters. The Dreamers has more characters, but they aren’t really fully-realized. And instead of using the multiple perspectives to highlight different aspects of the epidemic, the characters each approach the disease in much the same way.
Walker’s writing has a lovely quality to it, where it manages to be vivid without being overly flowery. However, the book is also written with a kind of dreamy detachment which — along with the slowly paced beginning and large cast of characters — made me struggle to get invested in the story.
Half-way through the book, I was still on the fence about whether to finish it. Walker does a good job of highlighting aspects of the sleeping disease that are compelling to consider. I appreciated the quiet drama of never knowing if someone is just sleeping or will never wake up. And while there are a number of intriguing plot developments, I kept waiting for something more.
The book explores the bonds that exist between the characters — what keeps them together or pulls them apart and the strength of their loyalty towards one another. But this theme, like all the other parts of the book, is introduced and sort of just dissipates, without doing much with it.
Without giving anything away, the ending is what finally soured my opinion on the novel. The ending is unexpected, but in the wrong way — it comes up out of the blue without a proper setup in the beginning. The plot events build up throughout the book, but simply fizzle away at the end, with very few explanations of anything. The character arcs end up being incomplete, and thematically, the ending seems disconnected from the majority of the book.
Mostly, I was left wondering what the point of the book was intended to be.
Read it or Skip it?
The Dreamers was a disappointing read for me, since I had enjoyed her debut novel and the premise seemed to be full of unrealized potential.
If you primarily read literary fiction and haven’t read much dystopian fiction, I think you might still enjoy parts of this book. However, if you’re well-versed in books with apocalyptic themes, I doubt this book will have much to offer you.
If you haven’t read Station Eleven, I’d highly recommend it if you’re interested in dystopian epidemic stories. Also, if you haven’t read her first book The Age of Miracles, I would recommend that book over this one.
(As a final note, I did like the design of the book cover, though.) Thank you to Random House for the opportunity to review this book. What are your thoughts if you’ve read The Dreamers? Is this on your TBR?
Definitely not on my TBR list…😊
haha yeah, thanks for reading though! happy 2019! :)
…and a very happy 2019 too🍾🍾
hm very interesting … look like I will be avoiding this …
eeek, I hate to deter people from reading but yeah I wasn’t a fan of this book unfortunately :(
Totally agree on the ending part! I needed more than that. And it wasn’t well thought tbh
yeah, I’m honestly confused why she would end the book that way, it just seems so random and unconnected to anything else :/
I have read lots of dystopian fiction and I am going to go with a pass on this one. Saving time in the New Year already. Thanks.
thanks for following the blog! and happy reading in 2019! :)
I just finished this last night! While I personally enjoyed the characters, I completely agree about the ending. I was definitely hoping for more.
I didn’t dislike the characters, I just felt like the character arcs were totally incomplete — the book seems to end instead of taking them on any sort of journey — thanks for dropping by!
I did get the book as an ARC. But thanks for the heads up. I think I will skip it.
hi Martie! if you end up reading it, would love to hear your thoughts! thanks for following the blog and happy new year! :)
I am so sorry that this book didn’t work for you, either! I was so disappointed with the book, and I agree with the Trolley Problem thread – I honestly imagined the character as one of Those Guys that take an intro to philosophy course and then start talking about the trolley problem and the ubermensch to sound cool… until it became more of a thing. Great and balanced review!
(also apparently I somehow have been unfollowed from your blog unintentionally. :/ fixing thaT RIGHT NOW!)
Good review! Most reviews have gone ga-ga over this book. Thanks for providing a different perspective.
thank you! yeah it’s always harder to put out a review that goes against the grain, so thank you for reading and for you comments! :)
Thanks for the review but I don’t have it in my tbr list..
Shame this was such a disappointing read for you- that’s fair about it not being good if you’re familiar with books with a dystopic theme though and I think I would have the same problem. Great review!
Agreed, Maybe it was just too overhyped but I was very disappointed
I have a strict aversion to books on epidemics oe people falling asleep, so this is thankfully a miss. Plus, have you noticed the number of books out in the past year with ‘Dreamer’ in the title. Have not read even one.
I’ve looked over this one a couple times, tempted to read. Sounds like I’ve made the right choice of passing it by. Thanks for your thoughts!